Ranking the Hamilton Tiger-Cats’ top 10 all-time passing quarterbacks

Ranking the Hamilton Tiger-Cats’ Top 10 All-Time Passing Quarterbacks

The Hamilton Tiger-Cats are one of the most storied franchises in Canadian football history, with a legacy stretching back well over a century. Over the decades, the club has been home to some outstanding quarterbacks who have left a lasting mark on the black and gold through record-breaking performances, Grey Cup runs, and unforgettable moments.

Here is a look at the top 10 all-time passing quarterbacks in Hamilton Tiger-Cats history, ranked by impact, longevity, and overall contribution to the franchise.

1. Danny McManus

Danny McManus stands alone as the greatest quarterback in Tiger-Cats history. He holds the franchise record for passing yards and touchdowns and led Hamilton to a Grey Cup victory in 1999. McManus combined durability, consistency, and leadership, making him the benchmark for all quarterbacks who followed.

2. Joe Zuger

A true legend of the CFL, Joe Zuger starred for Hamilton throughout the 1960s. He was a dominant passer in his era and helped guide the Tiger-Cats to multiple Grey Cup appearances, including a championship win in 1967. Zuger’s toughness and command of the offense made him one of the most respected players of his time.

3. Bernie Faloney

Bernie Faloney was one of the CFL’s most prolific quarterbacks during the 1950s and 1960s. He played a key role in Hamilton’s early success, winning multiple Grey Cups and setting passing records that stood for years. Faloney’s intelligence and accuracy made him a cornerstone of the franchise.

4. Jeremiah Masoli

Jeremiah Masoli’s career in Hamilton featured both resilience and elite production. After battling injuries, Masoli delivered several strong seasons, including a standout 2019 campaign where he finished among the league’s top passers. His leadership helped keep Hamilton competitive during a transitional era.

5. Zach Collaros

Although his time in Hamilton was shorter than others on this list, Zach Collaros made a significant impact. He led the Tiger-Cats to a Grey Cup appearance in 2014 and posted impressive passing numbers before injuries cut his tenure short. His talent was undeniable during his prime years in black and gold.

6. Bo Levi Mitchell

Bo Levi Mitchell’s stint with Hamilton came later in his career, but his experience and arm talent still earned him a place among the franchise’s notable passers. While best known for his success elsewhere, Mitchell contributed valuable leadership and production during his time with the Tiger-Cats.

7. Kevin Glenn

Kevin Glenn was a reliable and steady presence during his seasons in Hamilton. Known for his composure and accuracy, Glenn delivered solid statistical seasons and provided stability at the quarterback position during periods of change for the franchise.

8. Dane Evans

Dane Evans enjoyed several productive seasons with the Tiger-Cats, highlighted by a Grey Cup appearance and strong passing totals. He became known for his poise in big moments and his ability to lead the offense effectively when called upon.

9. Frank Cosentino

Frank Cosentino played during an era when the passing game was far less prominent, yet he still managed to leave his mark on the franchise. His contributions helped shape the early identity of the Tiger-Cats and laid the groundwork for future offensive success.

10. Kyle Walters

Before becoming a respected CFL executive, Kyle Walters spent time under center for Hamilton. While his passing numbers don’t match the legends above him, his role in the team’s history and contributions during his playing days earn him a spot on this list.

Final Thoughts

The Hamilton Tiger-Cats’ quarterback history reflects the evolution of Canadian football itself — from ground-heavy early offenses to modern, high-powered passing attacks. Each of these quarterbacks played a role in shaping the franchise’s identity and success.

As new eras begin and future passers emerge, these ten names will remain benchmarks for excellence in Hamilton football history.