Offensive struggles continue in poor conditions as Hamilton Tiger-Cats lose home preseason game to Toronto Argonauts

A rain-soaked afternoon at Hamilton Stadium disrupted what had initially looked like a promising outing for the Hamilton Tiger-Cats, who eventually slipped to a 20-10 preseason defeat against the Toronto Argonauts in their first exhibition game of 2026.

For much of the contest, the Tiger-Cats appeared to have the upper hand despite the narrow scoreline. However, difficult weather conditions ultimately proved too much for the team’s offensive depth, particularly as the game wore on. Heavy rain created challenging circumstances for both players and fans alike, with slippery turf, soaked footballs and reduced visibility turning the matchup into a battle of endurance.

Credit was due to supporters who remained in the stands despite the miserable conditions, though the challenges facing players on the field were arguably even greater. With roster spots still up for grabs, preseason games represent a major opportunity for fringe players to impress coaching staff, making the poor conditions even more frustrating for those hoping to make an impact.

The passing game struggled badly at times, especially under centre. Tre Ford endured a difficult outing, completing just two of his ten passing attempts for 14 yards. Meanwhile, Jake Dolegala finished five-for-14 for 61 yards but also threw an interception after a pass ricocheted off the arms of receiver Kyrese Rowan and into the hands of rookie Argonauts defensive back Ethan John.

Hamilton’s coaching staff appeared intent on evaluating Ford’s ability to operate within the pocket and execute plays on schedule rather than relying on his trademark improvisation. While his athleticism remains one of his biggest strengths, there were moments where timing and accuracy appeared uncomfortable, with open receivers missed and passes falling harmlessly to the turf. Ford did contribute on the ground, however, rushing twice for 17 yards, including a 12-yard gain on his opening snap.

Dolegala handled the conditions somewhat more effectively, showing confidence and velocity on his throws despite the rain. Yet accuracy issues remained a concern. He missed opportunities downfield, including an underthrown pass to an open target down the sideline that glanced off a defender’s helmet. Receiver Myron Mitchell was active with three catches but also experienced frustration due to misplaced throws that allowed defenders to recover and disrupt plays.

Though Ford received extended opportunities, Dolegala’s performance may have provided the Tiger-Cats coaching staff with something to think about in the race for the backup quarterback position. Both players are expected to receive another opportunity to strengthen their case in the rematch against Toronto later this week.

The ground game offered more encouragement. While Hamilton enters the 2026 campaign without a marquee running back, the rushing attack averaged an impressive 6.7 yards per carry across 22 attempts. Larry Rountree III particularly stood out, making a strong case for the starting role after breaking free for a 46-yard touchdown in the opening quarter and ending the day with 86 rushing yards on nine carries.

That scoring run came after veteran quarterback Bo Levi Mitchell had opened sharply, completing all three of his passes for 50 yards before exiting late in the first quarter. Mitchell looked composed and efficient, helping move the Argonauts defence onto the back foot through precise throws, including a standout 32-yard completion to receiver Kiondré Smith.

Despite the positives in the run game, concerns remain over Hamilton’s offensive line. Although pass protection generally held up well, the unit struggled to consistently create space for runners, frequently allowing defenders to disrupt plays in the backfield. For a team hoping to improve on last season’s middling rushing numbers, generating more push in run situations will be crucial.

Defensively, the Tiger-Cats showed encouraging signs for large stretches of the game. Hamilton started strongly, forcing early stops and regularly placing Toronto in difficult second-down situations. By limiting gains on first down, the defence dictated the tempo and kept the Argonauts from establishing rhythm.

Quarterback Chad Kelly produced occasional flashes for Toronto through the air and with his legs, but Hamilton’s defence remained disciplined early on and consistently forced punts. Defensive backs were active in stopping runs near the line of scrimmage, linebackers tracked plays effectively in open space and the defensive front generated pressure with only four rushers.

Although mistakes later proved costly, particularly as fatigue and weather conditions worsened, there were enough positives from Hamilton’s defensive effort to provide optimism heading into the remainder of preseason.