The 10 greatest quarterbacks in CFL history – fans still argue about who is No.1

The Canadian Football League has seen some truly exceptional quarterbacks over the decades. These players didn’t just win games — they defined eras, set records, and became icons for fans across the country. But when it comes to crowning the very best, opinions are divided, and debates about who deserves the No.1 spot still rage on.

Here’s a look at the 10 greatest CFL quarterbacks of all time, in no particular order, whose legacies continue to spark discussions among fans.

1. Doug Flutie

Doug Flutie is arguably the most electrifying quarterback the CFL has ever seen. Playing for the Calgary Stampeders and Toronto Argonauts in the 1990s, Flutie won six Most Outstanding Player awards and multiple Grey Cups. His scrambling ability, pinpoint passing, and flair for the dramatic made him a nightmare for defenses and a fan favorite.

2. Warren Moon

Before his legendary NFL career, Warren Moon dominated in the CFL with the Edmonton Eskimos. He led the team to five consecutive Grey Cup championships from 1978 to 1982, setting the standard for excellence. Moon’s leadership and arm strength made him one of the most feared quarterbacks of his era.

3. Anthony Calvillo

Anthony Calvillo spent his career with the Montreal Alouettes and is the CFL’s all-time passing leader. Known for his calm demeanor and incredible consistency, he guided the Alouettes to multiple Grey Cups while breaking numerous league records. Many fans consider him the epitome of a modern CFL quarterback.

4. Damon Allen

Damon Allen enjoyed one of the longest and most productive careers in CFL history. His mobility, durability, and leadership helped him win Grey Cups with multiple teams, and he ranks among the top all-time passers in the league. Allen’s career longevity alone cements his place among the greats.

5. Ricky Ray

Ricky Ray was known for his pinpoint accuracy and calmness under pressure. Over two decades, he helped Toronto and Edmonton capture multiple Grey Cups while consistently ranking as one of the league’s top passers. Ray’s ability to perform in big moments makes him a legend in Canadian football.

6. Henry Burris

Nicknamed “Smilin’ Hank,” Henry Burris led the Ottawa Redblacks to a Grey Cup win in 2016. Renowned for his toughness and leadership, Burris played for several CFL teams and consistently delivered clutch performances. Fans still debate his ranking among the all-time greats.

7. Tom Clements

Tom Clements had a stellar career with the Hamilton Tiger-Cats and Winnipeg Blue Bombers. Known for his football IQ and precision, he helped guide his teams deep into the playoffs and left a lasting impression on CFL fans.

8. Matt Dunigan

Matt Dunigan’s career was defined by pure arm strength and big-play ability. Playing for multiple teams in the 1980s and 1990s, he consistently lit up scoreboards and earned a reputation as one of the league’s most exciting quarterbacks.

9. Kevin Glenn

Kevin Glenn’s longevity and adaptability make him one of the most respected quarterbacks in CFL history. With over 20 years in the league and appearances for several teams, Glenn combined consistency with the ability to perform under pressure.

10. George Mira

George Mira made his mark in the CFL as a versatile and athletic quarterback. His ability to make plays both in the air and on the ground made him a standout performer during his time in the league.

The debate over No.1

Fans continue to debate who deserves the top spot among these CFL legends. Some argue for the dominance of Doug Flutie, while others point to Anthony Calvillo’s record-breaking consistency. Warren Moon’s dynasty with Edmonton and Damon Allen’s longevity are also in the mix.

What’s clear is that each of these quarterbacks left an indelible mark on the CFL, thrilling fans and shaping the league’s history.

Whether you value statistics, championship wins, or sheer impact on the game, the discussion over the greatest CFL quarterback of all time is far from settled — and that’s part of what makes it so exciting for fans.